Question · Retirement

Roth Conversion vs No Conversion: The Break-Even Math

The Roth conversion break even point is the future tax rate at which converting and holding still leave the same after-tax money. Work both paths on one hypothetical $300,000 IRA and the rate falls out of the sum.

AI-assisted, reviewed by the TrueMoneyTrading human editor: John James → 6 min read Published

Short answer

At the same tax rate now and later, converting and not converting end in the same place, as long as the money set aside for the tax grows at the same rate either way. Converting pulls ahead when your later rate is higher, when the tax comes from outside cash, and when RMDs and a taxed side account slow the no-conversion path. A lower later rate favors holding.

Two people each hold $300,000 in a traditional IRA. Both have a 22% tax rate today, a hypothetical figure. One converts the whole balance to a Roth IRA and pays $66,000 of tax from savings. The other keeps the IRA as it is and leaves that $66,000 invested in a regular brokerage account. Twenty years later, who has more?

It depends on rates. Get them on paper and the comparison stops being a matter of opinion.

Why do the two paths tie at equal rates?

Start with the clean case. Both portfolios earn 6% a year, the $66,000 grows at 6% too, and the person who did not convert pays 22% on the IRA when the money finally comes out.

It’s a dead heat. Converting moved the tax bill from the end to the start, and because multiplication runs in any order, paying 22% before twenty years of growth costs exactly the same as paying 22% after it, provided nothing else changes. The Roth or traditional IRA guide makes the same point for new contributions. For a conversion, the interesting part is everything that breaks the tie.

What happens when the side account is taxed?

Brokerage money pays as it goes. Dividends and interest are taxed every year, gains are taxed when you sell, and over two decades those small annual bills compound into a real shortfall against an account that pays nothing until the end, so call the result a 5% after-tax return on the side account, again hypothetical, against the 6% the IRA earns.

That gap comes from nothing but tax drag on the $66,000. Same rate in, same rate out, and the Roth still wins, because the money that paid the conversion tax would otherwise have spent two decades growing in an account the IRS taxes along the way.

Where the tax money comes from changes the result a great deal. Paying it out of the converted balance shrinks the Roth and removes the drag advantage entirely. That trade has its own page on paying Roth conversion tax from cash or from the IRA.

Where is the break-even tax rate?

Now let the later rate move. The Roth stays at $962,141. Its tax is settled. The no-conversion figure rises when the later rate falls and drops when it climbs.

On these assumptions, converting at 22% wins unless your later rate drops below about 18.2%. Above that, convert. Below it, hold.

The rule generalizes. With equal rates and the tax paid from outside money, the break-even later rate sits a little under today’s rate, and the gap between them widens with a longer horizon or a heavier tax drag on the side account. Shorten the horizon and the break-even rate climbs back toward 22%.

How do RMDs tilt the comparison?

The sums above let the traditional IRA sit untouched for twenty years. Once RMDs start, that stops. The IRS requires withdrawals from a traditional IRA starting at age 73 for current tax years, according to Publication 590-B as of November 2026, and the required minimum distribution page covers the later starting age for younger birth years and the table behind each amount.

Every RMD you don’t spend becomes another deposit into the taxed side account. Tax is paid, the remainder moves from 6% growth to 5%, and the drag compounds again.

Multiply that by every RMD year and the no-conversion path loses ground steadily. A Roth owner faces none of this. Publication 590-B states that the original owner of a Roth IRA does not have to take distributions at any age, so the converted money can compound at the full rate for life.

RMDs can also push the later rate up. Large forced withdrawals stacked on Social Security and a pension may land in a higher bracket than the one you convert in today, which is the case the lesson on filling low tax brackets before RMDs is built around.

What flips the answer?

Some things push the later rate up. Those favor converting. A surviving spouse who moves to single filing status often keeps most of the household’s income, including the larger Social Security check and the whole IRA, while losing the wider joint brackets that used to hold that income at a lower rate. Moving to a state with a higher income tax counts too. Rates may rise.

Others favor holding. A move to a no-income-tax state, large deductible medical or long-term care costs late in life, or giving IRA money to charity all reduce the rate the traditional dollars would actually meet.

Medicare premiums complicate the year you convert. A large conversion raises your income, and income above the Medicare thresholds adds an income-related surcharge to your premiums, which acts like extra tax on the converted dollars. The thresholds change every year, so check the current figures before sizing a conversion near them.

A conversion is permanent. Under IRS Publication 590-A, as of November 2026, any conversion in a tax year that began after the end of 2017 is locked in, and a market drop a month later leaves you with the full bill on a smaller Roth.

What if the money is going to your heirs?

The break-even rate above is your own. If you expect to leave the IRA to children, the rate that matters is theirs, and it can be very different from yours.

An heir who inherits a traditional IRA pays income tax on every withdrawal at their own rate. According to the IRS RMD FAQs, most non-spouse heirs of an owner who dies after 2019 must empty the account within ten years, and those withdrawals often land in their peak earning years. Run the same 20-year example with a hypothetical 32% heir rate and the no-conversion total is the $829,374 from the table above, about $132,767 short of the Roth.

A Roth inherited after its five-year period has run generally pays out without income tax, though the heir still faces the ten-year clock. If your heirs earn more than you will in retirement, converting at your rate and leaving them Roth money moves the tax to the lower-rate taxpayer.

How do you run your own numbers?

Write down four rates: your tax rate on the conversion, the rate you or your heirs would pay later, the IRA’s expected return, and the after-tax return on the side account. Fix a horizon. Then repeat the sums above with your own balance, and test your plan for withdrawals with the retirement withdrawal calculator. The free lesson on Roth conversions and the backdoor Roth covers how the conversion tax is worked out and the pro-rata rule that can raise it. Situations differ, and a tax professional can test the figures against your whole return.

Questions traders ask next

How many years does a Roth conversion take to break even?

There is no fixed count. If your later tax rate matches today's and the conversion tax comes from cash, converting leads from day one, and the lead grows each year the cash would have been taxed on its earnings. If your later rate is lower, the Roth needs years of untaxed growth to make up the difference, and a large rate drop may mean it never catches up.

Can I undo a Roth conversion if the market falls right after?

No. Since 2018 the IRS has not allowed a conversion to be recharacterized as a traditional IRA contribution, per Publication 590-A. The converted amount counts as income for that year whatever the market does next, which is one reason some people split a conversion into smaller pieces spread over the year.

Do my heirs pay tax on a Roth IRA they inherit?

Generally not on qualified distributions, once the owner's Roth has met its five-year period. Most non-spouse heirs still have to empty an inherited account within 10 years, according to the IRS RMD FAQs. An inherited traditional IRA is taxed at the heir's own rate, which may sit well above yours.