Question · Retirement

Roth Conversion Tax: Pay It From Cash or the IRA?

Paying Roth conversion tax from cash leaves the whole conversion growing in the Roth. Withholding is easier to set up, and before 59½ it can cost an extra 10% on the part sent to the IRS.

AI-assisted, reviewed by the TrueMoneyTrading human editor: James T. → 5 min read Published

Short answer

Pay it from cash in a taxable account if you have the money. Any amount the custodian sends to the IRS stays out of the Roth for good, and before 59½ the withheld part counts as an early distribution that can owe the 10% additional tax. Withholding still works when IRA money is all you have.

A $100,000 conversion at a hypothetical 22% rate adds $22,000 to your federal bill. The IRS collects the same $22,000 whichever account it comes from. What changes is where your money sits afterward, which is why people who can pay Roth conversion tax from cash usually do, and why the growth that cash gives up deserves a line in the sum too.

Assume the decision to convert is made. Whether converting beats leaving the money alone is worked through in the Roth conversion break-even guide. The rest is plumbing.

What happens when tax is withheld from the conversion?

The custodian splits the distribution. Part goes to the IRS. The rest lands in the Roth. Convert $100,000 with 22% withheld and $78,000 arrives in the Roth, while the full $100,000 still shows up as income on that year’s return, because the withheld slice was paid out of the IRA just as surely as the converted part was.

Before 59½, that slice costs more. The $22,000 sent to the IRS never reached the Roth. So it isn’t part of the conversion at all; it is an ordinary IRA withdrawal, taxable like the rest, and it can draw the 10% additional tax on early distributions, which on these numbers adds $2,200.

After 59½ the 10% charge drops away, though the Roth is still $22,000 lighter on day one.

Why does paying from outside money move more into the Roth?

A traditional IRA balance isn’t all yours. At a 22% rate, $100,000 of pre-tax money is worth about $78,000 after tax. The IRS holds a claim on the rest. The Roth or traditional IRA guide shows why the two account types come out equal when that rate holds at both ends.

Withhold the tax, and $78,000 of after-tax value becomes $78,000 of Roth money. Nothing new crosses over.

Pay from cash and the result changes. The IRA’s tax debt gets settled with $22,000 that was already taxed, so all $100,000 becomes Roth money, and in effect $22,000 of ordinary after-tax savings has moved inside an account where its future growth will never be taxed again, as long as later withdrawals meet the Roth rules for age and the five-year clock.

Doesn’t the cash lose growth of its own?

Yes. Left alone, the $22,000 would keep growing in the taxable account. Its dividends and interest get taxed every year along the way. So the fair test sets a full Roth against a smaller Roth plus the taxable account that kept its cash.

Cash comes out ahead in both cases. The margin is far smaller than the $22,000 headline. After 59½ the whole gap comes from one point a year of tax drag on $22,000, compounded for 15 years, so a heavier drag, a higher return or a longer horizon would each widen it, and a taxable account that is barely taxed along the way would shrink it.

Two more adjustments matter. Route B’s taxable account holds $23,736 of gains that haven’t been taxed yet, and selling it later will cost something, so the real gap runs a little wider than $6,988. Going the other way, if raising the cash means selling stock that has gained, the capital gains tax on that sale belongs in the cost of Route A. The retirement withdrawal calculator shows how each ending balance holds up once withdrawals start.

When does the IRS want the money?

Income tax is pay-as-you-go. A conversion in March raises that year’s bill in March. Waiting until the following April to pay can bring an underpayment penalty.

IRS Publication 505 for 2026 sets the test. You generally owe estimated tax if you expect to owe at least $1,000 after withholding and credits, and those payments cover less than the smaller of 90% of this year’s tax or 100% of last year’s. If last year’s AGI topped $150,000 ($75,000 married filing separately), the 100% becomes 110%. As of November 2026, the 2026 installments fall on April 15, June 15 and September 15, 2026, and January 15, 2027.

The prior-year test makes a large conversion easy to plan around.

Miss the safe harbor and there is still a fallback. The annualized income installment method, filed on Schedule AI of Form 2210, lets you show that the income arrived late in the year, so a payment made soon after a mid-year conversion can count for the period when the income actually came in.

Withholding has one timing edge. The Instructions for Form 2210 (2025 edition) treat federal income tax withheld as paid one-fourth on each due date unless you show otherwise. Tax withheld in December counts as if it had been spread across the year. If you already take RMDs, you can raise the withholding on the RMD to cover the conversion tax, skip estimated payments entirely, and leave every dollar of the conversion itself to land in the Roth.

What about state income tax?

States run their own rules. Some have no income tax. Others tax IRA distributions, conversions included, as ordinary income, and some exclude part of retirement income above a set age. A hypothetical 5% state rate on the same $100,000 adds $5,000. The choice comes up again. You can pay that bill from cash or let the custodian withhold it, and state estimated payments carry their own thresholds and dates, so check your state revenue department before the conversion goes through.

Which route fits which situation?

  • Under 59½ with cash on hand: pay from cash. Withholding adds the 10% charge and shrinks the Roth.
  • 59½ or older with cash on hand: cash still wins, by roughly the tax drag the cash would have paid.
  • Little or no money outside the IRA: withholding works. Smaller conversions spread over several years keep each year’s bill in a lower bracket, as the lesson on Roth conversions and the backdoor Roth sets out.
  • Cash would come from selling appreciated stock: count the gains tax first.

Situations differ. A tax professional can run both routes through your full return, state tax included.

Questions traders ask next

Can I take money out of the new Roth to pay the conversion tax?

You can, and it shrinks the Roth just as withholding does. Before 59½ there is a second cost. IRS Publication 590-B gives each conversion its own five-year period, and taking converted money out of a Roth inside that window can bring the 10% additional tax on the taxable part of the conversion.

Do I have to send an estimated payment right after a Roth conversion?

Only if you would otherwise fall short of a safe harbor. IRS Publication 505 for 2026 asks for estimated tax when you expect to owe $1,000 or more and your withholding and credits fall short of both 90% of the current year's bill and 100% of the prior year's. That 100% becomes 110% when last year's AGI topped $150,000.

Does my state tax a Roth conversion too?

It depends on the state. Some have no income tax at all, others treat a conversion like any other IRA distribution, and some exclude part of retirement income at certain ages. Look up your state revenue department's rules before converting, and add any state bill to the amount you plan to pay from cash.